Researchers matched the diets and genes of 20,940 women and found saturated fat was linked to more heart attacks and strokes, but mainly in one group
Two people can eat the same amount of butter, cheese and red meat and end up with very different cholesterol. Doctors have long suspected genes play a part, but dietary advice on saturated fat is still the same for everyone. A Stanford Medicine-led team looked at 20,940 postmenopausal women in the Women’s Health Initiative, combining their self-reported diets, fasting cholesterol and a genetic score for high cholesterol built from data on more than 1.6 million people.
The link between saturated fat and cholesterol depended on genes. In women with a genetic tendency toward high LDL, the “bad” cholesterol, eating more saturated fat was tied to a larger rise in LDL. In women without that tendency, the effect was smaller.
The same pattern showed up in heart attacks and strokes. Among the 25% of women with the highest genetic risk, those who ate more saturated fat were significantly more likely to have a heart attack or stroke. For the other 75%, eating more saturated fat did not markedly raise their risk.
That does not make saturated fat good for anyone. In women with low genetic risk, eating more of it showed no protective effect, even though their overall risk stayed low.
“There isn’t any evidence of a cardiovascular benefit to eating more saturated fat,” said senior author Shoa Clarke, an assistant professor of medicine and of pediatrics at Stanford Medicine.
The study, published in JACC: Advances, drew on women who joined the Women’s Health Initiative, a national US study launched in 1991. Their median age was 65. About half were white, a third Black and about 15% Hispanic.
Each woman reported how often she ate 122 foods and drinks over three months, and how much. The team first confirmed the well-known link: more saturated fat, higher LDL. Then they looked at how that link changed across the genetic spectrum.
The genetic score comes from a 2021 study in Nature by Stanford-affiliated researchers. It adds up the small effects of many genetic variants to estimate a person’s inherited tendency toward high cholesterol.
“There’s extensive heterogeneity,” Clarke said. “It’s really hard to extrapolate to everyone.”
A related early finding points the same way. Alexa Barad, a postdoctoral scholar in Clarke’s lab, presented work at a nutrition conference in July using data from a Stanford diet trial. People with high genetic scores were more likely to see their cholesterol rise after switching to a low-carb diet, and the rise tracked how much saturated fat they ate.
Heart health advice is getting more personal across the board. We recently covered what happened when people over 70 stopped taking their statins, and how healthy diets were linked to slower biological aging.
For now, the study is not a reason to change advice person by person. “We don’t yet have evidence that polygenic risk scores should be used to guide diet recommendations,” Clarke said. A practical clue many people already have is family history. If high cholesterol or early heart disease runs in your family, or your LDL climbs on a high-fat diet such as keto, it is worth checking your cholesterol and discussing your diet with a doctor.
There are limits. The diet data were self-reported, and the study is observational, so it cannot prove that saturated fat caused the heart attacks and strokes. Participants were mostly older women, so the results may not apply to men or younger adults. The press release does not give LDL values or risk figures for each genetic group.
The work was funded by an American Heart Association postdoctoral fellowship and the National Institutes of Health.
Source
Clarke S, Assimes T, et al. “Association between saturated fat intake and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol across the genetic spectrum.” JACC: Advances, 2026.
DOI: ADD-DOI-HERE