Child Development

A trial of 255 kids with ADHD tested the classroom accommodations schools hand out most, plus behavior therapy and medication. Only two made a difference

A trial of 255 kids with ADHD tested the classroom accommodations schools hand out most, plus behavior therapy and medication. Only two made a difference

Extra time on assignments, frequent breaks, a standing desk and a quiet place to work are some of the most common ways schools support children with ADHD. They are written into countless school support plans, but they have rarely been tested head to head. Researchers at Florida International University ran a randomized trial with 255 children from kindergarten to sixth grade, comparing those accommodations with behavior therapy and stimulant medication.

Only two of the approaches made a clear difference. Behavior therapy cut classroom rule violations by 37% compared with an ordinary classroom setup. Stimulant medication cut them by 61% compared with a placebo, and raised the rate of correctly completed assignments by 22%.

None of the four accommodations significantly improved classroom behavior or quiz scores, whether they were used alone or added on top of behavior therapy or medication. Some were linked to children getting less work done.

“None of the accommodations we tested had a significant effect,” said lead author Gregory Fabiano, a professor of psychology at FIU.

The trial ran inside FIU’s Summer Treatment Program, which gives children with ADHD structured classroom and recreational activities. Children joined between 2022 and 2025, and 235 of the 255 completed the study. It was published in JAMA Pediatrics.

It was a crossover trial, so children experienced different conditions in turn rather than being locked into one group. The researchers tested extended time, frequent breaks, standing at a desk and a low-distraction space, along with behavioral strategies and medication against placebo, and layered the accommodations on top of both.

The team measured how children behaved, how much work they completed correctly and how they did on quizzes.

The behavioral strategies that worked are not exotic. They included a daily report card, clear expectations, consistent feedback, praise, and rewards tied to each child’s own goals.

Fabiano’s explanation for why accommodations fell short is that they change the task without changing the child’s skills. “These approaches fail to build skills or address motivation,” he said. Extra time, for example, gives a child longer to finish, but does nothing to help them start, stay on track or care about finishing.

The study was co-designed by the late William Pelham Jr., founding director of FIU’s Center for Children and Families. His earlier research found that stimulant medication improved how much work children produced in class, but did not significantly improve how much they learned.

“A ‘one size fits all’ approach to ADHD doesn’t seem to be effective,” Fabiano said. “We need to rethink how we’re supporting these students.”

For parents, the practical point is not to drop accommodations a child already has, but to ask what else is in the plan. If a child’s school support consists only of extra time and breaks, it may be worth asking the school about a daily report card or a reward system built around specific goals, and talking to the child’s doctor about whether medication fits. Treatment questions come up for adults too, as in our report on which antidepressants hold up best over the long term.

Routine and structure seem to matter across ages. Adults with irregular sleep schedules had more depression and anxiety in a recent study of 23,000 people.

There are limits. The trial took place in structured summer classrooms, not regular schools, and the researchers say more work is needed to see whether the results hold in everyday classrooms. Some children may benefit from specific accommodations in ways an average across a group can hide, and accommodations can matter for things this trial did not measure, such as a child’s stress during tests. Fabiano reported receiving book royalties from Guilford Press during the study.

Source

Fabiano GA, et al. “Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Accommodations, Behavior Therapy, and Stimulant Medication.” JAMA Pediatrics, 2026.
DOI: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2026.5973